Valeo Electrification v Magna PT (CFI, ORD_56534/2024, 31 October 2024)
| Date | 31 October 2024 |
|---|---|
| Court | CFI |
| Division | Düsseldorf (DE) Local Division |
| Type of action | Application for provisional measures |
| Registry reference | ACT_39183/2024 · ORD_56534/2024 |
| Parties | Magna PT s.r.o., Magna PT B.V. & Co. KG, Magna International France, SARL v. Valeo Electrification |
Official decision (PDF) · UPC registry entry
Dhenne Avocats represents claimants and defendants in European patent disputes before the Unified Patent Court, including the Paris divisions.
Dhenne Avocats · 10 October 2026
Our analysis
Summary
By order of 31 October 2024 (UPC_CFI_368/2024, ACT_39183/2024), the Düsseldorf Local Division (R. Thomas, presiding and rapporteur, B. Thom, M. Bessaud, A. Sanchini) partly granted Valeo Electrification’s application for provisional measures against three Magna group companies under EP 3 320 604, which concerns a rotary electric machine. The injunction covers Germany and France, but supplies owed to BMW under existing commitments are carved out, on condition that the defendants provide security of EUR 500,000. The order shows how the division tailors an injunction whose effect on a third-party customer would be disproportionate.
Facts and procedure
The patent, filed on 7 July 2016 claiming French priority of 10 July 2015, was granted on 2 March 2022 and validated in Germany and France. Valeo targeted gearbox motor generators (GMGs) and the assembly incorporating them, supplied by Magna for several BMW models, including the Mini Countryman. The application was followed by an infringement action on 2 August 2024, Magna PT B.V. & Co. KG brought an entitlement action in Paris on 13 September 2024, and a revocation action was filed with the Paris Central Division on 4 October 2024.
The applicable law
Art. 62 UPCA and Rules 209 and 211 RoP allow provisional measures where the Court is satisfied with a sufficient degree of certainty that the applicant is entitled, that the patent is valid and that it is infringed or about to be infringed. Following the Court of Appeal (NanoString v 10x Genomics, 26 February 2024, Mammut v Ortovox, 25 September 2024), that degree of certainty is lacking if invalidity appears more likely than not. Rule 8.5 RoP attaches a presumption of entitlement to registration. Rule 211.5 RoP allows the measures to be made subject to security.
Question
Are the conditions for a provisional injunction met, and how should the patentee’s interest be reconciled with the harm a full injunction would cause to ongoing supplies to a third-party car maker?
Decision
Entitlement: Valeo, as registered proprietor, enjoys a strong presumption which can be rebutted in summary proceedings only if the title is manifestly erroneous. In Germany, no entitlement action was brought within the two-year period of Art. II § 5 IntPatÜG, in France, the action was filed more than six years after publication of the application. Whether Valeo is an inventor is left to the merits.
Validity: novelty over D1, D2 and D3 and inventive step over their combinations are not successfully challenged, claim 1 is not a mere aggregation, since its features interact technically. Infringement: the indexing member is present and need not be made in one piece, claims 1 and 8 are infringed by offer and distribution in Germany and France, while manufacture in Slovakia, where the patent is not in force, falls outside the order. Magna International France is jointly liable because of its sales support. The nomination letter grants no licence.
Urgency: time runs from when the applicant knew or should have known of the infringement, Valeo obtained an equipped vehicle in May 2024, analysed the product on 4 June and applied less than a month later. The one-month period mentioned in earlier orders is not a fixed deadline. Balance of interests: the injunction is granted, but the defendants may perform existing commitments to BMW as at 8 October 2024 for five model ranges, with no new customers or higher volumes, provided they post security of EUR 500,000 by 21 November 2024. Enforcement depends on Valeo providing security of EUR 2,500,000, penalty payments may reach EUR 250,000 per breach, the defendants bear EUR 14,700 of the EUR 21,000 claimed in costs on a provisional basis. The application is otherwise dismissed.
Key points for practice
- The presumption of entitlement under Rule 8.5 RoP yields in summary proceedings only to a manifestly erroneous title. A late entitlement action is not enough.
- General revocation statistics are irrelevant. A thinly reasoned contrary view of a European patent office does not bind the division.
- The division may carve supplies to a third-party customer out of the injunction where security would not make good the harm of a full ban.
- Practical point: a defendant disputing entitlement should bring an entitlement action promptly, a challenge raised only after the action carries little weight, including in the balance of interests.
Provisions applied
- Agreement on a Unified Patent Court
- Arts. 25(a), 47(1), 62, 69 and 73(2)(a)
- Rules of Procedure
- Rules 8.5, 209, 211, 220.1 and 224.2
- European Patent Convention
- Art. 54, Art. 60, Art. 69, Art. 138
- Directive 2004/48/EC
- Art. 9(3)
- Case law cited
- NanoString v 10x Genomics, Court of Appeal, 26 February 2024, Mammut Sports Group v Ortovox Sportartikel, Court of Appeal, 25 September 2024, 10x Genomics v NanoString, Munich Local Division, 19 September 2023, Ortovox Sportartikel v Mammut Sports Group, Düsseldorf Local Division, 9 April 2024, Novartis v Celltrion, Düsseldorf Local Division, 6 September 2024, 10x Genomics v Curio Bioscience, Düsseldorf Local Division, 30 April 2024, Ballinno v UEFA, Hamburg Local Division, 3 June 2024, outside the UPC: CJEU, 28 April 2022, Phoenix Contact, C-44/21
Prepared by Dhenne Avocats from the official decision, consulted on 10 October 2026. The database is updated every week, on Friday. Only the official text is authoritative.
Going further
Lexicon: Application for a preliminary injunction, Order to preserve evidence (UPC).
Publications by Matthieu Dhenne: The Launch Letter: How Generics and Biosimilars Should Write to Avoid UPC Urgency (Kluwer Patent Blog).
Source and translations
- Official source
- Unified Patent Court registry link recorded in the record
- Original language
- not recorded
- Translation available
- no translation recorded the firm’s French record is a summary, not a translation
- Date checked
- not recorded
Follow this case
Proceedings, related decisions, appeals, parties and patents as recorded in the registry and in the Dhenne Avocats corpus. Each link states its source.
Proceedings
Parties
- defendantValeo Electrification18 decisions in the corpusFollow this party
- claimantMagna International France, SARL12 decisions in the corpusFollow this party
- claimantMagna PT s.r.o12 decisions in the corpusFollow this party
- claimantMagna PT B.V. & Co. KG12 decisions in the corpusFollow this party
Decisions in the same proceedings and documented appeals
Contents of the record
- Nature of the act
- Application for provisional measures
- Outcome (Dhenne Avocats summary)
- La division locale de Düsseldorf interdit provisoirement à Magna l'offre et la distribution en Allemagne et en France des machines contrefaisant EP 3 320 604, tout en autorisant l'exécution des engagements existants envers BMW sous garantie de 500 000 euros. L'exécution est subordonnée à une garantie de 2 500 000 euros.
- Appeal
- No appeal documented in the corpus, this does not mean that no appeal was lodged.
- Instance
- First-instance decision, whether it has become final is not recorded.
Patents mentioned
EP 3 320 604mentioned in: summary of the decision, Dhenne Avocats analysis Follow this patent
Related decisions cited in the analyses
- Mammut Sports Group v Ortovox Sportartikel (CoA, ORD_44387/2024, 25 September 2024) cited in this record
- Novartis v Celltrion (CFI, 6 September 2024) cited in this record
- Ballinno v UEFA (CFI, 3 June 2024) cited in this record
- 10x Genomics v Curio Bioscience (CFI, ORD_598272/2023, 30 April 2024) cited in this record
- Mammut Sports Group v Ortovox Sportartikel (CFI, 9 April 2024) cited in this record
- NanoString Technologies v 10x Genomics (CoA, 26 February 2024) cited in this record
- 10x Genomics v NanoString (CFI, 19 September 2023) cited in this record
- Occlutech v Lepu Medical (Europa) (CFI, 20 August 2025) cites this decision
- G. Pohl-Boskamp v pharma-aktiva (CFI, 20 December 2024) cites this decision
Patents and standards
| Publication | Role in the dispute | Family | Standard and declaration | Pool | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
EP 3 320 604 | Patent at issue according to the summary or official headnote Also mentioned in 5 other decision(s): Valeo Electrification v Magna PT (CoA, ORD_68770/2024, 13 January 2025 · Valeo Electrification v Magna PT (CFI, ORD_68629/2024, 10 January 2025 · Valeo Electrification v Magna PT (CFI, 28 November 2024) · Valeo Electrification v Magna PT (CFI, ORD_60264/2024, 20 November 202 · Valeo Electrification v Magna PT (CFI, 2 September 2024) | not recorded | not recorded | not recorded | Espacenet links not checked mentioned in: summary of the decision, Dhenne Avocats analysis |
Receive an alert
Weekly summary of new records and substantive updates matching what you follow. Address confirmed by email, unsubscribe at any time, one email per week even where several of your follows match.