Bekaert Binjiang Steel Cord v Siltronic (CFI, 16 April 2025)
| Date | 16 April 2025 |
|---|---|
| Court | CFI |
| Division | Düsseldorf (DE) Local Division |
| Type of action | Request to review an order ex-parte |
| Registry reference | App_65278/2024 · ORD_69127/2024 |
| Parties | Siltronic AG |
Official decision (PDF) · UPC registry entry
Dhenne Avocats represents claimants and defendants in European patent disputes before the Unified Patent Court, including the Paris divisions.
Dhenne Avocats · 10 October 2026
Our analysis
Summary
By order of 16 April 2025 (UPC_CFI_539/2024, App_65278/2024), the Düsseldorf Local Division (Judges Thomas, presiding, Schumacher, sitting for judge-rapporteur Thom, and Zhilova) dismissed, together with all auxiliary requests, Siltronic AG’s application for review of the inspection and evidence preservation order made without hearing it on 18 October 2024 in favour of Bekaert Binjiang Steel Cord, proprietor of EP 3 212 356. The decision accepts that preservation of evidence may serve to prove the acts of use themselves, not only the features of the product, and may extend to delivery notes and invoices.
Facts and procedure
Bekaert Binjiang Steel Cord owns EP 3 212 356 on a shaped saw wire with controlled curvature at bends, in force in Germany, Austria and Italy and not challenged in revocation proceedings. Siltronic, a wafer manufacturer, buys saw wire from Bekaert and from the Chinese S. group. Having found remnants of 175 µm S. wire at a recycler in Freiberg, Saxony, Bekaert suspected Siltronic, which runs a major plant nearby. Siltronic refused to disclose its use of that wire and licence talks in summer 2024 failed (paragraphs 1 to 9). The order of 18 October 2024 authorised inspection of Siltronic’s premises in Munich and of logistics provider Hinterberger’s outdoor warehouse in Altötting, description and sampling of S. wire of 175, 150 and 100 µm, and seizure of documents on origin and delivery, such as delivery notes or invoices (paragraph 10). The measures were carried out on 11 November 2024 and Siltronic applied for review on 10 December 2024, seeking revocation of the order and, in the alternative, changes to the provisions on documents, additional confidentiality measures and return of the items seized (paragraph 12).
The applicable law
Review is governed by Rules 197.3 and 197.4. On the merits, the division relied on Art. 60(1) UPCA, which allows evidence to be preserved before proceedings on the merits, and on Art. 60(2), which covers seizure of the products concerned and related documents. The list in Rule 196.1 is not exhaustive, and Rule 196.2 allows the results to be used in the main action. Review looks for errors, if need be obvious ones, made by the court when issuing the order (paragraph 23).
Question
Must an ex parte evidence preservation order be revoked where the applicant made no test purchase, where the order targets the respondent’s acts of use and where it authorises seizure of delivery notes and invoices?
Decision
The application, admissible and filed in time (paragraphs 19 to 21), failed on the merits (paragraph 22). The interest in preserving evidence remained: asking Siltronic to hand over the wire was the obvious first step, the lack of a test purchase from S. did not exclude it, in a small market and after an earlier dispute settled in China, and the origin of the wire found at the recycler was, when the order was made, no more than a suspicion (paragraphs 24 to 27). Preservation may target specific acts of use: proving infringement requires proof of acts in the territory covered, if Siltronic orders abroad and takes delivery in Germany, importation is likely, and measures aimed at tracing the supply chain are not an impermissible fishing expedition (paragraphs 28 to 30). Documents relating to distribution fall within Art. 60(2), delivery notes and invoices are its typical proof, and referring the applicant to a production order in the main action would be circular, since the evidence must first be secured. The tax retention duty, which covers invoices only, does not remove the risk (paragraphs 31 to 33). The existing confidentiality regime suffices: Siltronic will be invited to assert its secrets before any release of the report, and if an action is brought the expert will hand the samples to the court rather than to Siltronic (paragraphs 34 to 36).
Key points for practice
- Review of an ex parte order looks for errors made when it was issued, assessed as at that date (paragraphs 23 and 27).
- Preservation of evidence may target acts of use, such as importation and delivery, and not only the structure of the product (paragraphs 28 to 30).
- Delivery notes and invoices may be seized at this stage, without waiting for a production order in the main action (paragraph 32).
- Practical point: a patentee should document its preliminary steps (a request to the respondent, reasons for not attempting a test purchase), as they ground the interest in preserving evidence.
Provisions applied
- Agreement on a Unified Patent Court
- Arts 60(1) and (2), 62 and 73(2)(a)
- Rules of Procedure
- Rules 186.5, 196.1, 196.2, 197.3, 197.4, 220.1(c) and 224.2(b)
- Case law cited
- No UPC decision is cited.
Prepared by Dhenne Avocats from the official decision, consulted on 10 October 2026. The database is updated every week, on Friday. Only the official text is authoritative.
Going further
Lexicon: Written procedure (UPC), Court fees and costs (UPC).
Source and translations
- Official source
- Unified Patent Court registry link recorded in the record
- Original language
- not recorded
- Translation available
- no translation recorded the firm’s French record is a summary, not a translation
- Date checked
- not recorded
Follow this case
Proceedings, related decisions, appeals, parties and patents as recorded in the registry and in the Dhenne Avocats corpus. Each link states its source.
Proceedings
Parties
- claimantSiltronic AGFollow this party
Decisions in the same proceedings and documented appeals
Contents of the record
- Nature of the act
- Request to review an order ex-parte
- Outcome (Dhenne Avocats summary)
- La demande de réexamen est rejetée avec toutes les demandes subsidiaires. L'ordonnance de conservation des preuves, y compris la saisie des bons de livraison et des factures, est maintenue.
- Appeal
- No appeal documented in the corpus, this does not mean that no appeal was lodged.
- Instance
- First-instance decision, whether it has become final is not recorded.
Patents mentioned
EP 3 212 356mentioned in: Dhenne Avocats analysis Follow this patent
Patents and standards
| Publication | Role in the dispute | Family | Standard and declaration | Pool | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
EP 3 212 356 | Mentioned in the analysis (role not qualified) Also mentioned in 1 other decision(s): Bekaert Binjiang Steel Cord v Siltronic (CFI, 19 November 2025) | not recorded | not recorded | not recorded | Espacenet links not checked mentioned in: Dhenne Avocats analysis |
Receive an alert
Weekly summary of new records and substantive updates matching what you follow. Address confirmed by email, unsubscribe at any time, one email per week even where several of your follows match.