ZTE v Samsung Electronics Italia (CFI, 24 July 2025)
| Date | 24 July 2025 |
|---|---|
| Court | CFI |
| Division | Mannheim (DE) Local Division |
| Type of action | Generic Order |
| Registry reference | ORD_33617/2025 |
| Parties | ZTE Corporation v. Samsung Electronics Italia S.p.A, Samsung Electronics France, Samsung Electronics GmbH, Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., Sams… |
Official decision (PDF) · UPC registry entry
Dhenne Avocats represents claimants and defendants in European patent disputes before the Unified Patent Court, including the Paris divisions.
Dhenne Avocats · 10 October 2026
Our analysis
Summary
By order of 24 July 2025 (UPC_CFI_850/2024), Judge Böttcher, judge-rapporteur of the Mannheim Local Division, confirmed his order of 20 June 2025 on the value in dispute in ZTE’s infringement action against Samsung Electronics and five European subsidiaries on EP 3 905 730, in which Samsung Electronics has filed a FRAND counterclaim. Having been heard, the defendants raised no argument justifying a different outcome at this stage. The order bears directly on the cost of FRAND strategies before the UPC: a FRAND counterclaim increases the value in dispute.
Question
Is a FRAND counterclaim a mere defence whose value merges with that of the infringement action, and does it benefit from the cap applicable to a counterclaim for revocation?
Decision
No on both counts. More than a mere defence, a FRAND counterclaim widens the subject matter and value of the dispute, at least where it is not confined to the patent in suit. The fact that the fee schedule does not mention such a counterclaim does not make it free of charge. The fee cap for a counterclaim for revocation does not apply by analogy, since the defendant may instead rely on the FRAND objection within the infringement proceedings. That the Munich Regional Court may require a counterclaim to avoid a finding of unwillingness is not decisive before the UPC. The value is readily derived from the difference between the royalties each party considers FRAND, a method consistent with the guidelines’ aim of simplicity. Samsung Electronics is not disadvantaged, since a successful counterclaim gives it more than a mere defence.
Key points for practice
- Practical point: a defendant must weigh the FRAND objection, which leaves the value in dispute unchanged, against a FRAND counterclaim, which raises it in line with the royalty gap and thus the costs at stake.
Provisions applied
- Other provisions
- Guidelines of the Administrative Committee for the determination of court fees
Related decisions
Prepared by Dhenne Avocats from the official decision, consulted on 10 October 2026. The database is updated every week, on Friday. Only the official text is authoritative.
Going further
Lexicon: Standard essential patent (SEP), FRAND offer and counter-offer, Injunctions and standard essential patents.
Dhenne Avocats blog: FRAND at the UPC: What the Court Has Decided, What Remains Open.
Publications by Matthieu Dhenne: Munich’s FRAND Guidelines: A Compass Drawn Too Finely, Tesla v. InterDigital and the FRAND Undertaking Inside the Pool (Kluwer Patent Blog).
Further reading: M. Dhenne, “Calculation of FRAND Royalties: An Overview of Practices Around the World”, European Intellectual Property Review 2019, vol. 41, no. 12, p. 754. M. Dhenne, “Conversant v LG: What about FRAND in France?”, European Intellectual Property Review 2019, vol. 41, no. 9, p. 585.
Source and translations
- Official source
- Unified Patent Court registry link recorded in the record
- Original language
- not recorded
- Translation available
- no translation recorded the firm’s French record is a summary, not a translation
- Date checked
- not recorded
Follow this case
Proceedings, related decisions, appeals, parties and patents as recorded in the registry and in the Dhenne Avocats corpus. Each link states its source.
Proceedings
Parties
- defendantSamsung Electronics Co., Ltd.24 decisions in the corpusFollow this party
- defendantSamsung Electronics GmbH23 decisions in the corpusFollow this party
- defendantSamsung Electronics Italia S.p.A.6 decisions in the corpusFollow this party
- claimantZTE Corporation11 decisions in the corpusFollow this party
- defendantSamsung Electronics France5 decisions in the corpusFollow this party
- defendantSamsFollow this party
Decisions in the same proceedings and documented appeals
Contents of the record
- Nature of the act
- Generic Order
- Outcome (Dhenne Avocats summary)
- La demande reconventionnelle FRAND n'est pas un simple moyen de défense : elle accroît la valeur du litige, sans bénéficier du plafond de la demande reconventionnelle en nullité, l'ordonnance du 20 juin 2025 est confirmée.
- Appeal
- No appeal documented in the corpus, this does not mean that no appeal was lodged.
- Instance
- First-instance decision, whether it has become final is not recorded.
Patents mentioned
EP 3 905 730mentioned in: Dhenne Avocats analysis Follow this patent
Related decisions cited in the analyses
- ZTE v Samsung Electronics (CFI, 20 June 2025) cited in this record
- ZTE v Samsung Electronics (CFI, 21 October 2026) cites this decision
Patents and standards
| Publication | Role in the dispute | Family | Standard and declaration | Pool | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
EP 3 905 730 | Mentioned in the analysis (role not qualified) Also mentioned in 5 other decision(s): ZTE v Samsung Electronics (CFI, 23 December 2025) · ZTE v Samsung Electronics (CFI, 20 June 2025) · ZTE v Samsung Electronics (CFI, 21 October 2026) · ZTE v Samsung Electronics (CoA, UPC_CoA_105/2026, 10 November 2026) · ZTE v Samsung Electronics (CoA, UPC_CoA_106/2026, 10 November 2026) | not recorded | not recorded | not recorded | Espacenet links not checked mentioned in: Dhenne Avocats analysis |
Receive an alert
Weekly summary of new records and substantive updates matching what you follow. Address confirmed by email, unsubscribe at any time, one email per week even where several of your follows match.